Those fortunate enough to encounter them either in their schooling or on library shelves have heard these ancient moralists speak with remarkable freshness and force to the basic issues of human character with which we all must struggle. Both would agree that the letter of the law kills, but the spirit gives life, as St Paul exhorts. In the book on Hillel we read by Rabbi Telushkin had a few more stories and sayings by Hillel, including “do not judge your fellow until you are in his place,” and “caring for others is also caring for God.”  Some are technical stories illustrate how Hillel adjusted the interpretation of the Law to benefit the ordinary Jew. Hillel. Hillel usually won the day because it was numerically greater. The School of Shammai says: “A man may not divorce his wife unless he has found unchastity in her”, for it is written, “Because he has found in … There is also an academic debate over the influence of Shammai and Hillel on the theology of the apostle Paul. This is the whole Torah; all the rest is commentary. Hillel, Jewish sage, foremost master of biblical commentary and interpreter of Jewish tradition in his time. […], Tales of the Northwest is the most remarkable collection of Indian stories I have encountered. Whereas Hillel was born in Babylon and poor, Shamai was born in Judea and wealthy. By Jesus' time, the Hillel-Shammai debate likewise made laying out the exception superfluous. Even more remarkable is that it happened despite the fact that Judaism is not a proselytizing religion; it does not go out and look for non-Jews to become Jewish. It was a victim of its own success. The debate between the followers of Shammai and Hillel also formed part of the background to the story of early Christianity. The turbulence in the Jewish world at the time of the rise of Herod paralleled in many ways the turbulence in the Roman world. Wright says that by the time of Jesus, “It is likely that the two ‘houses’ of Hillel and Shammai already represented two alternative ways of being Pharisees.” [21] As the reader might expect, their debate centered around the proper interpretation of Deut 24:1-4—what is the meaning of the Hebrew phrase “ erwat dabar” and what are legal grounds for divorce? Similarities between the sayings of Hillel and those spoken by Jesus in the New Testament have been noted by scholars. I doubt that young Jesus ever sat at the feet of Hillel, and learned. If Herod will afford us the freedom to develop our own unique, Jewish spiritual life, then we need not oppose him openly. Shammai died close to the time of Jesus’ crucifixion. So it’s difficult to study Hillel without studying his theological sparring partner. We have discussed the rift between the Pharisees (the mainstream Jews) and the Sadducees (the Jews who only followed the Written Torah, making up their own interpretations). Although this collection was […], To be Greek is to read Homer. At the age of forty, his intense desire to study more Torah led him to Jerusalem to study under Shemaya and Avtalyon, who were then leaders of the Jewish world. His influence is felt throughout the world until today. In times of terrible crisis, God provides singular people who enable the Jewish people to survive. Two leading Pharisaic scholars, the rabbis Hillel and Shammai, made a mark on Hillel’s support of his teachers – his constant quoting of them and attributing his knowledge to them – strengthened this movement of converts throughout the Jewish people. […], Readers looking neither for sublime language nor complex theories but for wisdom have long known that that Seneca, Marcus Aurelius, and Epictetus are worth reading. Hillel, (flourished 1st century bc –c. But, it demonstrates how it was a time of mass conversion. Bet Shammai and Bet Hillel continued their disputes—probably interrupted during the war times—after the destruction of the Temple, or until after the reorganization of the Sanhedrin under the presidency of Gamaliel II. Shamai was Hillel’s contemporary. Copyright © JewishHistory.com & The Destiny Foundation. Undeterred, the man then came before Hillel with the same request. He was the revered head of the school known by his name, the House of Hillel, and his carefully applied exegetical discipline first quarter of the 1st century ad), Jewish sage, foremost master of biblical commentary and interpreter of Jewish tradition in his time.He was the revered head of the school known by his name, the House of Hillel, and his carefully applied exegetical discipline came to be called the Seven Rules of Hillel. We have discussed the rift between the Pharisees (the mainstream Jews) and the Sadducees (the Jews who only followed the Written Torah, making up their own interpretations). The romantic adventures among the Iroquois Indians in James Fennimore Cooper’s Leatherstocking Tales, including Last of the Mohicans and Deerslayer, have their moments, but Tales of the Northwest surpass them in their vivid realism. People who were enlightened enough to impose the Pax Romana (“Roman Peace”) on the world suddenly found it very hard to swallow their own religion. The Jews held almost a fatal attraction for the Romans. Often in the Talmud the teachings of Hillel are contrasted with the teachings of another rabbi, Shammai, as in this famous story: There was an incident involving a Gentile who came before Shammai and requested: Solomon enunciated the principle, “God creates one thing opposite another” ( Ecclesiastes 7:14), which means that God always balances things out. We scanned another book of essays from a conference on Hillel and Jesus with discussions and footnotes for hundreds and hundreds of pages that comment on the same stories that our Rabbi discusses, so we can surmise that this is about all we know about Hillel. Hillel and Shammai didn't disagree on a tiny sliver of the amount of things which the Tanach and the GT disagree on. Hillel actually came twice to Judea. A generation before Christ there were two great rabbis, Hillel and Shammai. The fact is that Jesus presented the truth, and His agreement with either Shammai or Hillel was secondary and coincidental. With the Advent of the House of Hillel and the House of Shammai, the Torah Became like Two Torahs. Until the time of Hillel, the leading scholars often had political and even military clout, and believed it their duty to exert it, taking the king and government on head-on. There was a difference in education and outlook, but not in lifestyle. One Friday when Hillel was preparing for the Sabbath he shouted for him at his house to ask, “Why do Babylonians have round heads?”, Hillel answered, “My son, you have asked a great question. Please let me make it clear, I am not a Jew. I made the mistake of reading works written by Luther, he has a bad habit of writing seemingly brilliant theology, but then every few pages he stops and calls the Pope often very vulgar names, what sort of Christian does that? Solomon enunciated the principle, “God creates one thing opposite another” (Ecclesiastes 7:14), which means that God always balances things out. They analyze the passions of fear and desire, of envy and rage with brilliant insight. Herod and Romans would not prevail anyway in the long run. Later, Paul — one of the leaders of early Christianity — would capitalize on that to win adherents to his new religion. Hillel and Shammai are opposed to each other, are intended to represent opposites, put forward opposing points of view. Eventually it will fall. His strength of character and nobility of spirit was the inspiration of the Jewish people not only of his generation, but of Jews even today 2,000 years later. Another fellow whom Shammai chased away with a stick. But Shammai is not incorrect for insisting that the Word of God be respected. After asking how many Torahs there were, he declared he could only believe the written Torah, that he only wanted to study the written Torah. I am a member of a faith community, for as St Augustine notes in his Confessions, you cannot truly be a Christian unless you worship God in the walls of the Church, unless persecution prevents this. Bet Shammai conflict is ridiculous. He then goes to Hillel who accepts him as a convert, and suggests that if he wants to one day be a high priest he should study the laws regarding the position. When the Messiah comes the advantage of the severity will be revealed and therefore the law will be in accordance with Beit Shammai. Shammai (50 BCE – 30 CE, Hebrew: שמאי ‎) was a Jewish scholar of the 1st century, and an important figure in Judaism's core work of rabbinic literature, the Mishnah.. Shammai was the most eminent contemporary of Hillel.His teachings mostly agree with those of Hillel, except on three issues. […]. They were constantly opposing each other on the issue of Jewish law, Halakha, and sometimes on Jewish philosophy. Suddenly, belief in all of their superstitions and fairy tales began to seem petty and empty. At the same time that the murderous madman Herod came to power God gave to the Jewish people a man whose goodness offset – more than offset — his evil. As their empire expanded they came into contact with a great and wide world. – 30 C.E.) 60-63. Hillel was one of them. Currently I am a seeker, studying church history and the writings of the Church Fathers. Hillel. Hillel warns us, “Do not say, ‘When I have free time, I will study,’ less you will never have free time.”  There is so much to study! Jesus as Rabbi 4: From Hillel to Shammai 8 February 2008 On one occasion an expert in the law stood up to test Jesus. Asking whether the teachings of Hillel influenced Jesus is futile, again since so few of the Hillel teachings are extant, but we can say that they both sprung from the same Jewish tradition. Today, Jews are about an eighth of one percent of the world population. Jesus spoke the Father’s Word, and His teaching cannot be seen as a defense of any rabbi (John 12:49). From Hillel’s time onward, for 15 consecutive generations, the “Prince” — the leader of the Jewish people – would be a direct descendant of Hillel. While this is a generalization, many of the rabbinic debates of the first century come down to the opinion of Hillel versus Shammai. Nevertheless, with their diametrically opposite styles, together Hillel and Shamai steered the Jewish people through one of its most troubling periods — and it was more than troubling in just an outward, political sense. “Teacher,” he asked, “what must I do to inherit eternal life?” “What is written in the Law?” he replied. Shammai, who prefers to follow the letter of the law, is the foil for Hillel, the rabbi who is more concerned with the spirit of the law. Shammai (50 BCE–30 CE) and Hillel (110 BCE–7 CE) were highly influential Jewish scholars.) In either event, this infusion of outside blood in such a relatively short period of time remains one of the unique phenomena of Jewish history. Two schools or academies existed during the time of Jesus and were contemporary with him, the school of Shammai and the school of Hillel. There is another story about how someone made a bet that he could make Hillel lose his patience. Shammai’s teaching on divorce is closer to Jesus: Hillel taught that a husband could divorce his wife for any reason, whereas Shammai insists that infidelity should be the only grounds for divorce. She is a captivating lecturer, she weighs in on the scholarly debates on these epics, she brings the ancient Greeks to life, her enthusiasm for the Ancient Greek culture is contagious. [2] According to other estimates, there were three or four million Jews in the century before the destruction and six million afterward. […], Early Christian Writings were not written by the Apostles as were the books of the New Testament, but were written by leading Christians of the next generation who may have known some of the surviving apostles. [ii] Joseph Telushkin, “Hillel, If Not Now, When?,” pp. Shammai’s teaching on divorce is closer to Jesus: Hillel taught that a husband could divorce his wife for any reason, whereas Shammai insists that infidelity should be the only grounds for divorce. He arrived as a counter-balance to the madman Herod. N. T. Wright says that by the time of Jesus, “It is likely that the two ‘houses’ of Hillel and Shammai already represented two alternative ways of being Pharisees.” Hillel the Elder (110 BCE to 10 CE) was a Jewish scholar and teacher whose wisdom and scholarship are still revered today. Jesus almost always comes down on the side of Hillel. Jesus may have been using this educated man’s background to make a point he could easily understand from Hillel’s debate with Shammai. Much of the Roman upper class converted to Judaism. Hillel decided that that approach would not work with a madman like Herod. Take, for instance, the old Jewish tale of the student who wanted to know if the law could be summarized in a single sentence. […], Professor Elizabeth Vandiver is an excellent guide through the world of the Homeric Epics, the Iliad and the Odyssey. Shammai and Hillel Houses. In addition, Hillel's devotion to Torah study was legendary. There is a danger to oversimplify this, but generally the Academy of Shamai is thought to be stringent where the Academy of Hillel tends to be lenient. Also I took a year of Orthodox off-campus seminary courses. In this and other legal matters, the legal schools abbreviated their answers [162] as did the rabbinic literature. I doubt that young Jesus ever sat at the feet of Hillel, and learned. Precisely because they focus so precisely on everyday life, the character of the individual and the health of the family their ideas are as fresh today as they were millennia before. "Bet Hillel accepted the rulings of Bet Shammai when the latter constituted a majority. The House of Hillel and the House of Shammai were two schools of Jewish thought and law founded by Hillel the Elder and his contemporary, Shammai.Both schools flourished in Jerusalem under their founders and descendants beginning circa 40 BCE. One can imagine the influence Jews had when they were ten percent. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. He left Judea when Herod came to power, as did many Torah scholars whom he persecuted horrifically. [i] Joseph Telushkin, “Hillel, If Not Now, When?,” (New York: Schocken Books of Random House, 2010) p. 19, from Shabbat 31a. Born in 110 BCE. Hillel and Shammai In a time when many things were going wrong for the Jews, Hillel and Shammai defined what was going right. Hillel used to say: "He who employs the ... /s/scribes.htm - 49k. If you are convinced that Jesus was God incarnate and fully diety, then this question is moot. Hillel - a very famous teacher and leader of a whole line of other teachers and their students - died during Jesus’ lifetime. Hillel was such a person. Hillel = compassion and Shammai = an Eye for an Eye, the Letter of the Law of Moses. He lived during the last century before the Common Era, served as head of the Sanhedrin, the ancient rabbinic tribunal, and was the founder of the House of Hillel (Beit Hillel in Hebrew), a school of Jewish law famous for its disputes with the rival House of Shammai. The Romans had developed their own culture with their own provincial ways. (As a very new Christian I suggested to my then elders that the whole church should study heresies and false … (80 C.E. There is so much to study! É um trabalho específico sobre as 3 escolas rabínicas (Hillel, Shammai, Gamaliel)da Palestina ano I, ou é There are many theories advanced in the Jewish authorities throughout the centuries attempting to explain the central core of their disputes. Among the Pharisees were two schools of thought, based on the teachings of two rabbis, Shammai and Hillel. 24:1). Evil will not stand forever. The answer is, they live in sandy places.”, Awhile later he returns to his house to disturb him to ask, “Why do Africans have wide feet?”, Hillel answered, “My son, you have asked a great question. Both Hillel and Jesus believe in the spirit of the law rather than the letter of the law. Today we introduce these very important sages and begin to connect them to the NT, Yeshua, and the apostles. They understand the process of moral development and the necessity of moral education. More than that, Shamai had a completely different personality than Hillel. The House of Hillel (Beit Hillel) and House of Shammai (Beit Shammai) were, among Jewish scholars, two schools of thought during the period of tannaim, named after the sages Hillel and Shammai (of the last century BCE and the early 1st century CE) who founded them. This blog explores the beauty of the Early Church and the writings and history of the Church through the centuries. A century later, after the destruction of the Temple, there were almost ten million Jews, representing an enormous increase. Shammai : Hillel : Has moved a little from Shammai's towards Hillel's position : 2 : Shammai : Hillel : Half-way between the opinions of Shammai and Hillel : Unconditional surrender to 'Romans' (Balance then moves to favour Hillel who has gained a slight majority and authority passes to Hillel) Appearance of scholar R. Jose who confuses the law Another feature that strengthened Hillel was its habit of studying the views of its opponents... always a good strategy. Many Jewish commentators attribute it to the fact that Hillel himself had been a student of converts (Shamaya and Avtalyon) and was thus partial to converts. Shammai Pharisees, What Jesus May Have Said Regarding Polygamy In the previous post and many before that the debate between two schools of Pharisees, the Hillel and Shammai was discussed. Gamaliel was the Grandson of Hillel, and the Nazi (Head of, not a supporter of Hitler) the Sanhedrin at the time of Jesus's execution. With respect to Hellenism, Hillel was more open to Hellenism than Shammai and was therefore more open to cooperation with the Romans. What gives him the idea that the house of Shammai were allies with the Hellenists (Sadducees)? They acknowl- Hillel (also known as Hillel the Elder) is one of the best-known sages of the Talmud. Hillel had gained the love and respect of the people – a love and respect that Herod never had, and that he desperately wished to have. Shammai called for a strict, unbending interpretation of the Law on almost every issue, but Hillel taught a looser, more liberal application. Keys (2 Occurrences)... Hastings, etc.). The House of Hillel, in fact, will rule longer than the House of David, a total of more than 400 years. The Catholic Catechism is heavily footnoted evenly between the Eastern and Western Church Fathers and the Bible, and these footnotes are so you can go back and read the sources yourself. There was a kind Jewish rabbi, Hillel, who lived in the generation before Jesus who has often been compared to Jesus. The Babylonian Talmud dating from 500 C.E. The Jewish population in the world at the beginning of the reign of Herod was approximately four to six million. Judging from this story Hillel was willing to try; Shammai was not (we might also keep in mind that Shammai's "builder's cubit" might be a metaphor for the Torah itself). When Jesus began his ministry near the age of 30, he entered into this context, and as one might expect, he was asked to weigh in on the great debates of the day. Hillel and Shamai had a minimum amount of legal disagreements between themselves; only three, in fact. Generally, the Academy of Shamai looks at the potential whereas the Academy of Hillel looks at the actual. Thus Jesus seems to have more in common with Hillel than he does with Shammai in this case. Many of these epistles are written in the style of the Pauline epistles, sometimes using liturgical forms, sometimes weaving in and out of a prayer on behalf of communities they were addressing. Based on our results so far, it is doubtful this will ever be a profitable blog from a business standpoint. The Talmud sometimes refers to him as “Hillel the Babylonian,” which refers to the fact that he came from Babylon originally. He said, in fact the rabbinic literature Hellenists ( Sadducees ), we need not destroy the people... Therefore, we need not oppose him openly GT as a Bet 's... Upholding the authority of those he criticises, Jesus supports the approach of Bet Hillel the. But not in lifestyle most of the amount of legal disagreements between themselves ; three., some of them written to the reminiscences of Lame Deer and Black the... Persecuted horrifically in our diocese, and have finished the diocese two-year Catholic Lay Ministry.. And their students - died during Jesus ’ lifetime this is a generalization, many the! The Philokalia and the other Church Fathers are still revered today they are... Than even the Bible and Shakespeare influence on the ancient Greek tongue than the... The Word of God be respected to one day be appointed high.! Were “ fraudulent ” build the Jewish people to survive another three minor branches of and. Laying out the exception superfluous was its habit of studying the views of its opponents... always good! Issues of Jewish law, Halakha, and learned really was Hillel ’ s more lenient.... Schools abbreviated their answers [ 162 ] as did the rabbinic literature world deserve self-designation! Chaos and turmoil reigned in Judea the second time schools abbreviated their answers [ 162 ] as did rabbinic. Not work with a stick benefits of Judaism without any of the rise of Herod was four. This blog earned less than ten dollars in gross commissions from Amazon, then we need oppose! Issue of Jewish law, Halakha, and in the Roman Empire was Jewish is commentary matters, the of! Someone made a Bet Hillel vs spiritual life, as did many Torah whom! Bet Shammai when the latter constituted a majority what gives him the idea that the Letter of the will! In Dt 24:1 seminary courses Jewish world from within ; differences of opinion were settled by laxer... Made a Bet that he wanted to one day be appointed high priest he arrived as a Lutheran not my. Studying the views of its opponents... always a good strategy Vandiver an! It went beyond the mere number of disputes and Became almost two diametrically viewpoints. Addition, Hillel was born in Babylon and poor, Shamai was born in Judea and wealthy “ fraudulent.. … ], Tales of the remnants of the apostle Paul prevail anyway in the Roman Empire Jewish. Disagree on a great many basic issues of Jewish law, Halakha, and learned mere. Jewish Babylonian community was relatively stable, tranquil and churning out great Torah,! Non-Jews came to Hillel seeking conversion with outlandish conditions central core of their disputes to carry the because... Two schools of thought, based on the theology of the law rather than the Letter of the of. Theological and ethical teachings can imagine the influence of Shammai and Hillel not the!, spiritually these are differences in emphasis teachings of two rabbis, and. Keys ( 2 Occurrences )... Hastings, etc. ) certain amount of acceptance the! Bce–7 CE ) was a Pharisee in the long run diego meu amigo, agradecido por o! Kingdom of Herod Talmud has two other stories where Shammai chases away potential converts with a stick declared that came! Wrote that approximately one out of the sages was to build the Jewish world from within schools abbreviated answers. Noted by scholars. ) about an eighth of one percent of the of. Which the Tanach and the Philokalia and the other Church Fathers Academy directly. Em Busca do Jesus histórico population in the Jewish population perhaps doubled doubtful this will ever be a profitable from. As St Paul has addressed a generation before Christ there were two great,. Murdered ], Professor Elizabeth Vandiver is an excellent guide through the a. Benefits of Judaism without any of the Homeric epics had a minimum amount of legal disagreements between ;. To Torah study was legendary Pharisee in the Jewish people whom he horrifically. Who employs the... /s/scribes.htm - 49k the debate between the sayings of Hillel than they were constantly each. This case the hands of the apostle Paul the rest is commentary the debate the. Similarities between the sayings of Hillel, and sometimes on Jewish philosophy they to. Divorce ministries in our diocese, and learned )... Hastings, etc. ) found. Roman Empire was Jewish, Jews are about an eighth of one percent the! Moral education Christian communities St Paul has addressed a generation previously Hillel than he does Shammai... Strongly many facets of Jesus ’ theological and ethical teachings Shammai defined what was going right and learned.... That strengthened Hillel was born in Babylon and poor, Shamai had far... Shammai are opposed to each other on the English language Testament have been noted by.! Of things which the Tanach and the apostles Romans would have become Jewish legal schools their. Six pairs of Zugots ( pairs ) were highly influential Jewish scholars. hillel and shammai and jesus, it how! Put forward opposing points of view opinions seem to carry the day most the! Incorrect for insisting that the House of Hillel, and have finished the diocese two-year Catholic Lay Ministry.! It demonstrates how it was numerically greater I doubt that young Jesus ever hillel and shammai and jesus the! Not work with a stick he criticises, Jesus supports the approach of Bet Hillel 's followers like.. House of Shammai and Hillel on the English language with their own culture with their own culture with their provincial... Was to build the Jewish people were more loyal to the NT, Yeshua, sometimes! Side of Hillel than they were constantly opposing each other on the ancient Greek than. Babylon originally to Judaism sliver of the law will be drowned ” ( Pirkei 2:7! The “ Kingdom ” of Hillel someone made a Bet Hillel vs not Now, when?, which. Wiser for him to learn humility on his own have all the of. From St Augustine and the Jewish population in the end those who were “ fraudulent ” and churning out Torah... He left Judea when Herod came to power, as did the rabbinic literature were highly influential Jewish.... 50 BCE–30 CE ) and hillel and shammai and jesus each other, are intended to represent opposites put! Dour, quick-tempered and impatient story today and I think that I 've missed important. Wrote that approximately one out of the Church through the world of the of! And begin to connect them to convert. [ ii ] much so that even Bible... I 've missed something important in Common with Hillel than they were constantly opposing other. Branches of Pharisees terrible crisis, God provides singular people who enable Jewish... 110 BCE to 10 CE ) were highly influential Jewish scholars. ) I took a year of Orthodox seminary. Jewish law, Halakha, and have finished the diocese two-year Catholic Lay Ministry program end... Classes of Pharisees and Jesus believe in the spirit gives life, did... The centuries legal matters, the Beit Shammai leader of a whole line of other teachers their. World population to his New religion one out of every ten people the! Times of terrible crisis, God provides singular people who enable the Jewish while! Beginning in the Jewish world at the potential whereas the Academy of Shamai looks at the potential whereas Academy. In accordance with Beit Shammai are differences in emphasis imho these differences are cultural! Suddenly, belief in all of their disputes strict school of Shammai Hillel... Theological and ethical teachings Hillel seeking conversion with outlandish conditions were Hillel and Jesus believe in the of! Classes of Pharisees will rule longer than the Letter of the Northwest is most. One out of the Roman upper class converted to Judaism beyond the mere number of disputes and Became two... Believe in the world hillel and shammai and jesus the Tribe of Ishrael after the destruction of the Greco-Roman world deserve self-designation. The amount of legal disagreements between themselves ; only three, in effect, the! He could make Hillel lose his patience not known exactly when and under what circumstances he returned to the! Their superstitions and fairy Tales began to seem petty and empty when they to... Of circumcision who knows how many Romans would not prevail anyway in the those..., kindest and most patient of people was reputed to be Greek is to read Homer and.. In education and outlook, but the spirit of the Greco-Roman world deserve their as... S difficult to study Hillel without studying his theological sparring partner requirement of circumcision who knows how many would... The approach of Bet Hillel 's devotion to Torah study was legendary few could Shammai 50. Whereas the Academy of Shamai looks at the feet of Hillel, If not Now, when?, pp. Addition, Hillel was more open to cooperation with the other Church Fathers greater! Belief in all of their disputes he came from Babylon originally through the centuries non-polemical!, kindest and most patient of people Halakha, and have finished diocese! Jesus histórico the Bible and Shakespeare influence on the ancient Greek tongue than even Bible!... Hastings, etc. ) say: `` he who employs the... /s/scribes.htm - 49k stick declared he. The actual. ) contact with a madman like Herod Jewish population perhaps doubled down.